Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Des Donnelly's avatar

Most interesting, thank you for your opinion and time (the most valuable thing)

Perhaps one of the most futile / irritating things on the planet is 'make me top, somebody from Ballygobackwards promising to list you on SE page 1 for a few hundred...

It does seem that the LLM 'selection' of urls' is based on training data and is way beyond SEO/SERP, wow what a relief. Imagine a 20 year advance in just 1 year, now we are moving forward again...

Expand full comment
Tumithak of the Corridors's avatar

This is a really interesting peek at where browsers might be going, but I’ve got mixed feelings.

On one hand, I completely get the appeal: no more drowning in tabs, no more re-entering the same info across a dozen websites. The idea of an “agentic browser” that actually works for you sounds promising. But there’s one question I can’t shake: whose agent is it, really?

If these tools live in the cloud, built by, hosted by, and ultimately controlled by big tech, then it’s not really my agent. It’s more like a concierge with a side gig in selling my data.

I’d love to see a browser like this where all the computing happens client-side, with no phoning home and no silent syncing. But realistically, most users won’t have the local horsepower to run something that complex. That probably means these agents will need to be cloud-based, which changes the nature of the relationship.

Instead of giving us more control, we might end up with a more polished version of the attention economy, where the highest bidder influences what I see, how I interact, and even what I get to know.

I still use different search engines. Sometimes I even scroll to page three. Not because I’m nostalgic, but because I’m not always looking for the most popular answer. I want the right one, or at least a broader perspective. Will AI agents preserve that kind of choice, or quietly smooth it out of existence?

Agentic browsers could be extraordinary tools. But only if we stay absolutely clear about where they run, what they store, and who they actually serve.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?